President Donald Trump tweeted that the group switched their stance on lockdown measures. That is false.
WASHINGTON — The Confirm workforce exists to deliver you the info as a result of we all know it isn’t at all times straightforward to know what’s actual on social media.
A type of clarifications comes from a latest tweet by President Trump, who claimed that the World Well being Group switched their stance on present lockdown measures.
“The World Well being Group simply admitted that I used to be proper. Lockdowns are killing nations all around the world,” reads an Oct. 12 tweet.
A second tweet reads partially: “WHO not likes lockdowns, simply got here out towards.”
However is that basically true? Let’s Confirm.
QUESTION: Did the World Well being Group reverse its stance on lockdowns?
ANSWER: No, the WHO didn’t change steering on lockdowns. Its opinion has stayed constant since April, warning that lockdowns could also be mandatory at occasions to manage circumstances, however must be used provided that mandatory due to the implications.
The group by no means declared that Trump “was proper” on his COVID-19 response, both.
An emailed assertion from the World Well being Group, and a number of official statements the group launched earlier this 12 months.
We’ll begin with the assertion. This is what the group mentioned when requested in regards to the President’s tweets:
“Our place on lockdowns and different extreme motion restrictions has been constant because the starting,” it reads. “We acknowledge that they [lockdowns] are expensive to societies, economies and people, however might must be used if COVID-19 transmission is uncontrolled. In case they’re used, it must be as a final resort…”
So then is that this, as President Trump claims,a change from what the group mentioned earlier within the pandemic?
This is a part of WHO’s steering from April 14:
“Bodily distancing measures and motion restrictions, sometimes called “shut downs” and “lock downs,” can sluggish COVID-19 transmission by limiting contact between individuals. Nevertheless, these measures can have a profound detrimental influence on people, communities, and societies by bringing social and financial life to a close to cease.”
The report continues to state that for nations which have launched “widespread bodily distancing measures and population-level motion restrictions, there may be an pressing must plan for a phased transition away from such restrictions in a fashion that may allow the sustainable suppression of transmission at a low-level while enabling the resumption of some elements of financial and social life.”
That steering remained the identical just a few months later, at this briefing on July 13.
“We have to attain a sustainable state of affairs the place now we have enough management of this virus with out shutting down our lives totally, or lurching from lockdown to lockdown; which has a vastly detrimental influence on societies.”
So we are able to Confirm that the World Well being Group tips for lockdowns has stayed constant since April.