‘We have to act for the Amazon and act for our planet,’ mentioned Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau when fires ravaged the Amazon rainforest in August 2019. He was joined by many Western nations in preaching the virtues of defending the ‘international frequent’ for combating local weather change.
However the Western world’s concern for the worldwide commons appears to restrict itself, up to now, to the delicate ecosystems within the southern hemisphere. Thus, there may be a world treaty to guard the Antarctic, which places an indefinite ban on mining and hydrocarbon extraction. Moreover, there’s a long-standing demand, pushed by the G7 nations, for a world treaty to guard the tropical forests as a result of they’re essentially the most biodiverse areas and ‘Lungs of Earth’.
Nonetheless, in terms of the northern hemisphere ecosystems, the identical nations reject any worldwide intervention. The Arctic is a traditional case of this double normal. In 2008, the 5 coastal states of the Arctic Ocean (United States, Russia, Canada, Norway and Denmark) vowed to dam any “new complete worldwide authorized regime to manipulate the Arctic Ocean” within the Ilulissat Declaration.
The Arctic is crucial for the soundness of the earth’s local weather, arguably much more than the Antarctic. Its sea ice helps average the worldwide local weather. In flip, it is usually very delicate to adjustments in local weather. Consequently, the Arctic is warming extra quickly than the worldwide common, and its sea ice has decreased dramatically for the reason that late Nineteen Seventies.
The warming of the Arctic can be rushing the melting of the Greenland ice sheet. Current research point out that Greenland’s ice is melting on common seven instances quicker in the present day than within the Nineteen Nineties. Subsequently, the adjustments within the Arctic have huge ramifications on sea degree rise, aquatic ecosystems, and climate patterns the world over, together with the monsoon.
However the sea ice melting has additionally opened up the fabled Northwest Passage, considerably shortening the route between the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. As well as, Arctic seabed is now accessible for oil and fuel extraction and deep-sea mining. As an estimated 40% of present international oil and fuel reserves are on this area, there’s a scramble over delivery lanes and assets, particularly between the Arctic states. However different nations are additionally staking declare over the area’s assets, particularly China.
India is an observer on the Arctic Council and has not too long ago launched a draft Arctic coverage. Regrettably, the draft coverage lacks objectivity. It’s an ‘all-of-the-above’ coverage with contradictory objectives. On the one hand, the coverage envisions India’s position in exploring and exploiting hydrocarbon and encourages investments by Indian firms. Alternatively, it additionally expresses deep issues concerning the impacts on the nation because of the adjustments within the Arctic, together with on the monsoon, and proposes a slew of analysis actions. In conclusion, the draft phrases the Arctic as ‘the frequent heritage of mankind’ and requires ‘sustainable, accountable and clear’ human exercise.
However ‘sustainable, accountable and clear’ exploitation of the Arctic is an oxymoron. It’s inconceivable to take out oil and fuel, burn them, and nonetheless hold international warming underneath test, or open the worldwide delivery lane and anticipate the ocean to stay pristine. The irony is that the world’s wealthiest individuals, dwelling within the already rich Arctic states, will achieve essentially the most by exploiting the assets. Nonetheless, the prices shall be borne by the world’s poorest, dwelling within the coastal areas of the worldwide South.
If India desires to be a severe participant within the Arctic, then its coverage should handle this irony and the double requirements of the Arctic states. You will need to realise that we made a mistake by changing into an observer within the Arctic Council, thereby accepting the Arctic states’ sovereign proper over the Arctic ocean. We are going to repeat the error if we be part of them in exploiting the Arctic.
The underside line is that India won’t achieve economically however is more likely to lose massively attributable to coastal flooding, monsoon disruptions and adjustments within the ocean methods. Subsequently, India’s Arctic coverage ought to push for a world authorized mechanism, much like the Antarctic treaty, and save the Arctic’s pristine ecosystem and earth’s local weather. On this endeavour, it’d discover allies within the Biden administration, which has simply cancelled the Arctic Refuge oil programme and Keystone pipeline.
Views expressed above are the writer’s personal.
END OF ARTICLE