WASHINGTON — The U.S. Agency for International Development is instructing its staff in Washington to shred and burn documents, according to an email obtained by NBC News. The move comes as President Donald Trump’s administration faces legal challenges over its attempt to shut down the federal agency.
The document destruction was set to take place Tuesday, according to an email from Erica Carr, the agency’s acting executive secretary. It is unclear how many people received the email, which thanked workers for their “assistance in clearing our classified safes and personnel documents.”
“Shred as many documents first, and reserve the burn bags for when the shredder becomes unavailable or needs a break,” Carr wrote.
Burning or shredding of classified material does happen during certain scenarios — including in emergency situations — but some former employees, as well as an organization representing foreign service workers, say that the current directive is inappropriate.
A State Department spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Harold Koh, a legal adviser for the State Department during President Barack Obama’s administration, said the move was not standard procedure, noting steps like this are instead typically taken when an embassy is under attack.
Outside of emergency scenarios, “the priority is preservation for later consultation and continuity of sound policy,” Koh said.
Koh pointed to a ruling from U.S. District Judge Amir Ali, which was upheld by the Supreme Court, in which Ali said that the Trump administration could not block congressionally appropriated foreign aid funds from reaching intended programs and agencies. He said that because of Ali’s ruling, documentation showing how funding was authorized and appropriated “should be preserved until the funds are fully expended.”
A former USAID official said they had never seen something like this before but also noted the unprecedented nature of everything going on with the agency.
“USAID never gave their lease away and had to evacuate their headquarters before,” the person said.
The American Foreign Service Association, a group that represents foreign service officers, also weighed in, with a spokesperson saying it was “alarmed by reports that USAID has directed the destruction of classified and sensitive documents that may be relevant to ongoing litigation regarding the termination of USAID employees and the cessation of USAID grants.”
AFSA joined Oxfam America and other government employee unions in filing a motion Monday to block the Trump administration from shutting down USAID.
“Federal law is clear: the preservation of government records is essential to transparency, accountability, and the integrity of the legal process,” the AFSA spokesperson said.
“The Federal Records Act of 1950 and its implementing regulations establish strict requirements for the retention of official records, particularly those that may be relevant to legal proceedings,” the spokesperson continued. “Furthermore, the unlawful destruction of federal records could carry serious legal consequences for anyone directed to act in violation of the law.”
The spokesperson said AFSA was closely monitoring the situation and urged USAID leadership to “provide immediate clarity on this directive.”
The director of the National Security Counselors, a law firm that focuses on national security, said that USAID’s move would not violate the Federal Records Act if “everything they’re destroying is digitized completely.”
“If this is just a cleanup crew and getting rid of excess records, it begs the question of why they’re in safes to begin with. That is fine,” the firm’s executive director, Kel McClanahan, said. “But that is not what this sounds like.”
“This sounds like the Trump administration is going in and acting as though it’s an embassy about to be overrun and they’re destroying the documents to keep them out of the wrong hands. But this is the Ronald Reagan Building,” McClanahan added, referring to the building that housed USAID’s headquarters.
He said he has reached out to the National Archives, asking for a halt in document destruction.
“These are not the actions of someone looking for true waste, fraud and abuse,” McClanahan said. “This is slash and burn mode and not leaving any evidence behind that could disprove their narrative.”
The Trump administration has targeted USAID, slashing the agency’s workforce. Crews removed signs from the USAID’s headquarters in February, and at the end of the month, USAID workers were given 15-minute slots to retrieve their belongings from the agency’s headquarters.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said in a post to X on Monday that his department was “officially cancelling 83% of the programs at USAID.”
